I'm going to begin a behavior system with a student on Monday who has a hard time keeping his hands off others, uses inappropriate language and gestures, and has on multiple occasions told kids to do bad things or the opposite of what I'm saying. My behavior clip chat doesn't work for him, and his reprimanding at home apparently doesn't either. I'm going to try with him having two Cups (1 and 2) and 5 Popsicle sticks. He gets to move 1 stick from cup 1 to cup 2 for each block/subject transition if he was well behaved and made good choices. At the end of the day if he has all the sticks moved to cup 2 he will get to choose a reward. This will be a daily thing. My question is....should I be able to move one of his already moved sticks in cup 2 back to cup 1 if he does wrong, or should he be able to leave his already moved sticks in cup 2 even if he turns around and makes a bad choice? Suggestions?