I had a treasure chest in both my student teacher and my first year. My master teacher just let kids go whenever she caught them doing something good or if they got 100% on their spelling tests. Last year, I sat kids in groups and had a point system. Certain groups got points all day for having everyone in their group staying on task. At the end of the day, the group with the most points got treasure chest at the end of the day. I really don't want to put the kids in groups (I have them in a horse shoe). I don't really think it was fairly done the way my master teacher did it either (it seems like the same kids get chosen every time). I am at a loss thinking of a way to fairly do treasure chest this year. Any ideas would be appreciated.